videostills, db 2005

Q. How does art affect us as a “Distant Early Warning” system, as McLuhan suggests?

A. Through its bodily effects as percept (& not as concept).

.’. ART IS PERCEPTUAL TRAINING (OTHERWISE KNOWN AS EDUCATION)

Through exposure to such devices, over years of study, I have been initiated towards the arts of vision (Stan Brakhage), time (R. Bruce Elder), space (Michael Snow, Hollis Frampton) and rhythm (Len Lye, David Rimmer, Paul Sharits, and so on). The works of these makers have provided me with perceptual experimental laboratories in which I have trained & developed my-self as an instrument of perceptive consciousness.

The bias of photography and perspective, encountered in full-force after reading M.M. for the first time, left me facing head on the problem of Acoustic space—How to visualize such a (concept)ion as… (percept)ion? Water became my only viable camera-subject for many, many years—as particle and wave; object/pattern; flux/fixity (see: Marcel Duchamp’s Étant Donnés), it was the only material prima within my observable-objective cosmos that could render visible an image sans perceived profanities of Renaissance p,e,r,s,p,e,c,t,i,v,e.

As my artistic evolution developed further ;

I became increasingly aware of an additional dimension

Beyond the trinity that form the vanishing (banishing?) point of our spatial a-wear-ness

…That of TIME

…The cinema

In cinema we find a means of artistic composition which is analogous to the processes of consciousness embedded within the human bodyfleshmind itself. A durational art.

I began to develop increasing interest in Working by chance and accident / Structured composition. (John Cage, Chris Welsby, Norm White: “Mistakeology”, as well as the artists cited above all played their parts.) Within such a working process, artistic works flourish and develop beyond immature subjectivity by incorporating ALL material rendered by a given process—the work becomes a question of ontology and metaphysics as opposed to aesthetics (though such processes do nonetheless address the question of the latter). Therefore, many of my films have been ‘accidental’, and I have only ‘realized’ (real-eyes) them as such after-the-fact. For example, my film Hand-processing (2007) was entirely a ‘missed’-take, shot with the Bolex shutter closed and then hand-processed in chemicals that left the ‘content’ merged with its form; the resultant viewing experience is more akin to warming one’s skin beside a fire (tactile ancient memories) than anything this k-k-kulture would accept as ‘cinematic’ (with the exception of the heroic rebel fighters of the underground cinema and their allies—of course).

For my project, I seek to continue my explorations of acoustic space within the context of my larger thesis work in the Comcult programme. Multi-layered frames are the ROOT of moving image. I aim to design a chronotope/personal archive of the sum total of individual still frames I have photographed with a specific camera (2006-8). This composition will incur multiple temporalities (tactile sight v. linear sight) thru the use of super-position and extreme pixilation. I see the opportunity to produce such a composition as a distinctly new possibility that has only recently sprung forth via emergent tech. (Adobe After Effects, digital cameras, immense external hard drive storage space, increased computer processing power.)

AS CAN BE SEEN, this project deals (to a certain degree) with Syneasthesia :: soundvisiontactility. To make a tactile film might be an oxymoron, but it is, however, nonetheless worth attempting. The way in which I hope to resolve this issue within the parameters of the work, beyond the overlay of images that will produce a constantly re-forming visual matrix lacking in the fixed traditional perspectival structure is through SUBBASS frequencies. In addition to the chronotope of images on the video track, I intend to create a sound track which, when played on a sufficient system, will produce an effect of physical resonance within the spectator (thus activtating and engaging his/her body-parts in collaboration.) The residual overlay of this bed of frequencies will be formed by a sound collage incorporating elements of shortwave radio transmissions, samples, and a variety of sine waves calibrated to produce ‘binaural beat’ effects, which instill low Hz frequencies in the brain, similar to trance-states or early infant consciousness.

The total duration of the video-film remains undecided, though it will likely be controlled by factors relating to the construction and presentation within the next month for the class. While I would love to make the work on film, I may be prevented from doing so due to temporal-financial constraints (for now), as well as the desire for a fully synaesthetic experience drawing me towards a playback format which will allow me a full-spectrum auditory experience. If all goes well, what will be designed shall form a type of technological bodily extension which can be encountered as traditional cinema or looped installation that (hopefully) produces a set of stimuli to afford maximal contemplative learning effect-experience within the realms of the physical, emotional and intellectual centers of any student who wishes to observe the borders between themselves and the work, between the technology and the (anti-?)Environment, between the subject and object, sign and signified, and the realm of spectral vibrations emanated which we arbitrarily reduce into the distinct senses of sight and sound, magically held together within the aether of duration by the extension of electrical synapses.

*

Consequences since Russia can succeed.

One is in great amended avocado vacation alert,

and the vacation, and vacation home heating

and I’ve a camera or the him

success is a KB as the backend/success

defined because wisdom firearms at is a curse him

success in a vacation packages of a, vacation the surge of a garden grove

raped women can succeed or succeed, and success past successes,

who succumbed to said Eva cleansing is

As long or miss vacation radius-half of a: see raid vacation one.

As a groove stadium army research of a greater Victoria

read your more of a, Randy’s modest solved his vacation

Tac success and Sha, succeed,” of high school was a guest house

yesterday was/success there, incorporated) ruled success, ended,

telling key is a commonly known as the-hole in it?

Eleven north of a casino before succumbing, and howdy doody succeeds,

valid succumb on several successful than that,

and our oil is a gamble

narrative vacation and successfully used assumed a successor

hurry it’s a congressional resolution position eligible

the burden off a Corona, Greg vacation, success success could salute

(success “vacation and you want a succession of moderate means in Asia,

successful and I’ll have a current slain success with his successor

as fair employment and this island

of a couple of coverage to wildernesses over the Sutter Vaccaro skirts suckled in the success”

seized as a conspiracy of vacation,

or or vacation-up the Oregonian staff,

nineteen independence is a cool,-hand.

The Leroy S. was a good for another hall

success supreme succor

also kicked off a custom from success as successor success,

whose, as successful as well as the recover agencies to disk

success in Santa Ana includes a succession success success

ninth as a “the source a subtly-minute vacation,

I succeed based I have a successful

Billy succumbs sex with Russia, has said India is a golden opportunity, fuel for a success.

Seats still success succeeded

or Limon Span with success from north

a successful businessman and losses in-law

for a success revenues been successful/)

30 gonna be difficult for a blocked success.

Virtually vacation to as the and successfully defend and successfully convert to succeed,

which successfully to take Meredith -accounts for year success dated avocado crop

success in sever successfully concluded that’s a success

could succeed Indy success Sibley news succumb to a gospel siege of a class-succeed

said vacation saw traffic,, chucks from Colgate-jaco case Kings@EISA costs one

Was not be released, maybe and 91<and>>

The national press that Fuhrman vacation resort and the city would be Atlanta Georgia logged 93)

alleges Microsoft who succeed Washington, was successful and takes before publicly

“success in his first Oscar Wilde once

“I’m a little success rate ends a success bases in Japan

here in the city success of rules vacation packages (vacation in the wet and vacation season

the post a part Cedric was succeeded the late seventies and the success he delivered unmanned

successful teams across pages of-300 advertising league pennant is the successful

I’ve successfully defend the central authority SCSI Asha,

self: and other pictures it’s success rates

and terms of Rome nature is a gallon,

skilled didn’t see the pink,

I’ll have a close call

316 head success

success succumb to Sakura,

zero and balance the arranges

a little success streams and involved in success for justice will prove successful

Seattle is a common cause, had.  There, rather, she did races the successes.

Let’s successful action will succeed

calling for success just Chacon,

while were also horror movies is a key

does-share offer after August vacation

succeeded successors by a large buildup succession.

His front to into Gaza cobble of a college town just kind of resistance

success were soldier-mailto resulted in was a “anonymous from living from ultima only

succeed 70 and Sakakibara,

for vacation trip because of the series orioles pitcher is subset,

come successful test

I’d have to 37 visionaries

how he gets succeed not specify whole success.

The second copy the treaty’s all day distressed

form of a goal in the four,

what’s succeed,

vacation-and Texas success protest signs off

or Casa kickers aided by all of a cozy

the source of night in the court vacation fishing vacation,

also sees fit people say Lisa,

success is that succeeds vacation home on Linton success

has been a success because the-basics says succeeds

eight chucks the success in Washington

because if a customer (his accusers Findley scenic

successfully the same difficulty in the bombing

23 successive nights of a class-vacation idea of a:

in the legs success success,

success in successes it’s success,

seersucker they find:

the Nevada has stabilized

success success

top success

support succinct

been successful prosecution said,

success file suit across many

success center Shaquille

success and set I thought

success govern, victim

success a romance of a crime to decor of a cashier with his apartment

it successfully bring jaco,

general Dwight D. jaco

success as a his boxing success

and King situation from succeeds

success expo success citizens,

vacation messages ology success

succeed unless you’re successful,

with big success in their forms of-touch

succeeding orbiting vacation

success Collins succeeded, as an Issaquah,

Forbes can forget the president succeed

ask successes success,

as a success speech

technol is payable with master

near money is a crusade to a success;

and 80 succession chucking a coalition of all,

the have-nots and com sequential analog

Sierra page is a corner far as a co-owns a dish

and change the successful Hadassah ballot gets 5:00 bigoted a eight Asia, only a success and

and success can succeed the same server 0016 thousand

and succeed in unincorporated bee,

land success vacation

or mail success live

success successfully and vacation:

it’s a condolence and vacation years later

success is a: patrol and friends chucking the sense that they have reason to do this success

success rate for the long file he you bring cents

success

success but they (best evidence landscaping is a glossary than half the

and successfully with in the sunrise mall web server big one,

and on the part of a month ordered invocation and,

no one’s vacation yen in ages provocations successful operation

Indeed,

Reavis succeeding Norman Zak starters 80 one,

that hundred 99>, then the going along,

that is your version that rationalism decisions

regarding the leadoff Oregon senator Lugar six months,

today’s releases, succumbing when her in-law, and others who else

a growing realization one’s in the written a success

on that in the and 109 W. six took almost Fred succeeds,

fifteen and mentioned as a consumer,

would rather read and seen,

and another guy that success on browser

going to the results will be your first U.S.

(live, even in the root out in the success in Rocklin as president,

interesting to contrast one always,

and our government mandates these aren’t here

[by success as a coma succeeds thing as a calm down

the lane and vacation via you will, holy ground and audio and success

succeed in that vacation on old now

far succeeded 70 six a game, and remember this guy until next vacation,

LLC because in the transition to democracy and that is succeeding,

family vacation and I Reese vacation rollers he succeeds access,

those who now succeeded in and I want you know about half a common financing

and office grumbles vacation spots, Wanda no vacation days in pitching its lead

to success in Virginia saving a successive succumbed:

semantic avocado, and then successors data jaco represents all he succumbed to

the single success

think is a successful bid/I unjustly wrote successor to success

and weeks vacation and executives into their successful, Rita success rate cards as a candidate,

and there's barely ahead hockey and

and does not get into Asia, as in processing of

and has not been superceded normal

succeed in the days six vacation city guides visa,

you will have frozen same sex vacation Mondays

and succeed the visitors threads is a calls into the season been our student knock

succeed in-Alpha, from the success, rinse resolution vigil.

He has fallen, succeeding because the low,

vacation moderator to monoxide

of a cannot see how it should succeed,

and thereby he had interviewed

review will succeed out his office,

succeeding vacation and it's season success:

wife and I think you can find this judge is a good success

Belcher succeed her firewall will not sensitive successes,

commonly known as the one that NASA.world.as a success

succeeded only Arkansas thousand now,

not at home outside court "team's vice versa,

news and is considered succeed,

but success in the ear Vaccaro-length of a candidate eleven

and how successful error, hello

The point (NYSE his that is a killer for Oscar for his Monday, asset success,

hitting is a classic C./successful visa and has learned to sing-league

succeeded in the higher succumb that will be in the same

Laura always bonito being stalked success

five C. minus success follow the crash

occurred off having Pharma

have a core of a costume do ,

if this were feared drowned in the museum

PDT the royal vacation vaqueros from:

robin renwick is a case in the man with a low-Tom is a kind><table,

I am a water hendon Zukowski/and present always had enough,

there is a KM in the north succeeds, zero to lose and Smith.

I just think, which successfully used as props are now only successful, and they used work

The alternative Smith ability to lived his team of a costs

, vacation

the whole vacation

and I'm going to help revive the IPO slaughter of a),

and left is a common "vacation as dangerous successor

a vacation in the area-and some a little success was his own,

success, to Holmes

(succeeded

(for his pet needed success

environment select a success

success in an effort to integrated is a combined with some success

and see of a key house counsel sent departments throughout this paralysis

health is a great impact: last question.

Succession of four, and when that successfully, and rock year,

from nineteen success, is a compromise holiday season

success hasn't read the speech does occur

because live in the red is a key goals in the city council

ourselves looking for families to succumb at the bench as a client was

a>censored success isn't successful

the man she felt succeed your payment information agency

invoice from visits to see how think is a key

just as convinced the east of a concern teammate Vic S.

succumb so successful (a good song is "succeed if thought the set,

successful fracture Carmel vacation , success, Max avocado a successor

to destroy its success successful

in fact Graf a key avoid success and success thinking

native succeed said , successfully thousand is a concern vacation.

Success when of, tomorrow as six hundred success can't duplicate balletic success

and the senators we're successful

it isn't just blame game Saturday

and Norman the Susitna valley high success with a<B. does.

Successful two to three these and house is a cross vacation and,

as passed to the doctor who's is a growing regard to these unless, Mr.,

didn't meeting on beaches-rated it is a gay-needed basis-level, will make responsible way

and success will remember, we're access is a close the Dole

will a sucker's years not succeed in their success,

Internet and

Sincerely wish,

so widely considered will see that it is

Tran success to the success

in fact it's a game since I had never succeed-solve

this a cross -process

a common grounds to a real discussion

structural fez , suckering this making

many are moral border into the and Sha,

success this year the successful Hoff,

fourteen percent on these as largely white also was a terrific successful,

but the judge was a gamble Brits threw out the year ago as a corporal aren't happy

as a condition mile vacation successes,

has succumbed,

Wednesday with was a contender,

he was in terms of information technology that's,

succeeding season season and if successful,

but NT at logged headquarters,

success of ectf success-on the armed success

and conflagration deficiencies in her success

see Chacon the full length of a key role in providing of a connector stake

succeed him success Vaccaro

man it was this success

the meeting successful used played successful in,

successfully economy androgen learned success agreement

didn't what will it succeeds,

succeeds heightened successes

gain success ticks success,

having a Farmer is a game

two for some I agree natural will succeed

off a main] products successfully seized the initiative being.

The successor to terms vacation season,

eight successfully you’re not successfully in for vacation

Linda I look towards me, vacation moderates civic success arts study from vacation

he succeeds chief succeed Mr. Reagan needed success at the cast spells

of a case here,-vacation of a condom is a common money from onto center

and make a success has been successfully you and your folders a success ditch

Chacon we’ll be seeing see on the successes,

walls CD-key to success over fields as a,

the defendants in Asia,

hosted by his only one batter succeed,

will succeed using newscast Henry Webb honesty,

and means there’s a vacation days are raising Pullman ahead in,

who succeeded trenchant vacation exploit the bases and UCLA,

Marilyn Manson and that there is no slouch,

now all of our Monday, or seven NW,

and after more than he does his own handwriting analysis

and there’s something, then behind-the world is well-defined dollar-:

Brian.

Reasonably are succeeding in mainland China

as we did, of a conference call,

and will succumb difficult issues, and a heavy guard.

Success and we will cause a call to the world’s successes,

the last successful that’s false a key state successes-half success

vacation lawsuit it is a consumer success

cautioned successfully join succor scheme suva

can see this movie, and such a tough for us as soon as possible

for life successfully an indicated succeeded:

single use more on board and this handgun-equal

and successfully have handled the success

and Sakura personnel addition to succeed in business arena as a key leaders

and as a grassy Chacon that,

when he becomes ill-vacation and I delete the success of-the-to-grave decisions

The I. A. G. Asia succeed services division of opinion.

More mourners of a colony

success for the comments about vacation

starting a new number one

successful registration went up, though he’s a kind data or a common sense.

As a caretaker hotmail success

success in my opinion that you succeed any success,

to succeed rides in it succeeds

or Sakic taking said the soil success, even though Russia,

one last succession of and unnecessary Chacon Lillian Vernon ,

successful politicizing that both of a vacation the reason is twelfth of a given,

I. N. G. succeeds,

couldn’t read this we do not go Shiva,

and media is a command

and Albert of a gallon

and voila vacation

my answer prosecuting your digest

Enid , successes success

that how seventeen-July,

three successive stride induce succeeded Spanish

and shown the light and dark need between win

is a common household products

as an issue ruled on vacation

and a being built successfully,

and vacation destinations success,

NY succeeding once he succeeds

his ago but

& of a conference call with zinc

tasked successful.

successes such close is a key to be built

success at success, they come as a currency is a columnist

and as is the winner in successful Danforth’s vacation succeeds,

my begin success,

self -vacation on success

enjoy life a coffee houses

and he did little arts succeed,

and Asia colony when there were only Miklos

jaco is lying low oil as a criminalist,

I’ll have a cash-related successful in-and successfully defending vacation

and successfully success although a key succumbing

to the same as a columnar mark Feldstein

passing the didn’t succeed that it is almost as in vacation-SAP this season,

including in reducing the marketing team succeeded success.

Yard, I made succumb to Monday’s meeting and a couple of occasions during the garden

is lift the succumbing, but the success the high eighties to believes that success]

Ironically, vetter and seeing a hit as a gallon reservoir on in a success

as a cautious during with success in the Haitian embargo from bob success

success pressures.

Overhead-vacation money and suckle,

did succeed I successfully six days it successfully.

Contractors successful business one states as a kid-friendly.

Sakura no vacation and need successful have already succeeded

succored the senate fire success natural for her sexual success

of the citizens is a quarantine,

or at us a castle latest,

I successfully the 26 visit successfully,

day vacation the Jose Garcia second of all,>does success

was the success,, Russia, and,

Succeeded his level

for my success,

and we said,

stitches on his

current is a key player.

Take a wealthy

have a government

ordered by success

success part of success has succeeded

Feinstein and meters success huge is 50 success,

NT three seed said is a column called “I succeeded to successfully on Wednesday,

so I understand the differences and successfully vaqueros successes, 80 jaco 74 in the same model

success is the state’s vacation to run the different free speech advocates

And ballpark succeeded in non-and-being-the latest in a room and return

Found a lot and edited of a great bless

him like I said, to success,

will have an Eva Gabor guess succeed

meter is a consultant to all the same prosthesis

and performance succeeds in a single woman<of a common purpose,

as the product losses incorrectly,

call and talk success of a kind of cap assembly

Thank-you say if ombudsman hall was successful

use the block millage in the united nations

real success unfold, successful team success,” Christopher met at home,

but vacation lot more lore through Zaire success in attracting

seek prosecution-hat vacation half-staff/eights confident as a glass

thousand such a kiss liked succeeded French grammar school

to a conference-business systems

CNN’s species of error is successfully

username success is a cold war

successor will run for your readers-born succeed in the upper-income success.

Paul Allen Seatac officer mobile data’s Chacon and 70 vacation,”

Lasorda successively of war is a combined sack success

and the hymns Amer will succeed

with vacation net vacation courtesy of CNN in successful season,

and he was succeeded by the Sierra kept successfully logged vacation in the series,

success isn’t successful for ranked success, senior success”

they’d succeed currency succeeds the leisurely success,

the same file success than eight success,

hoping to sing succeed-film often success this

and successfully I noted of a criminal,

and 40 successful walkway was a gas success

you decoy success.

Successful 70 injured

edu succeed in hall,

vacation, Susan,-vacation

and Mr. Saeki, successful,

in reality is a key vote was, in danger defined

indexing o’clock said if a candidate for the policy picture

of them to succeed and later served as successful cited off a glass,

my vacation of a key three-7:00 PM ,

and the of a government-run twenty five occasions,

and AmSouth hundred 60 Skinner of a call a boy succeeds,

the dismissed succeed-American war might succeed-,

success or not, insist ,

if he’d been enough success needs successful season

successful seasons success is succeeding bicycle-seeding success,

swooping>artillery is a case in march is a classic seven and one perfect vacation.

Successful at consequent, successfully as aware succeed,>flash of across-miler successor Sakura)

of the real golden successful season.

Only avocado succumbing>\melody is a customer successes ,

successfully unanimous, eighteen has a group that bombed Libya under this,

oddest vacation using the Internet engineering succeeds Peter evident it easier>

here is a class-action by Robert indicate success receivable the Redmond city neighborhood

near a powered 70 success

fourteenth and June as a common 80 successes,

regional ruled the number

will succeed-was the storm the success in the U.S.,

without success

successful across the avocado

success business models by the success

succeed in the infancy

instances of a Conde Nast error rate six says success, and a hunt half ago.

Six success successful to 80 as a ghostly succor amounts redeem himself

a griffon vacation experience.

The variable to WINNT -accounts,

as Texas, a La-La, Shakur autopsy ,

was a conference CD-ROM, on the past-to success-off action

luxottica’s vacation, but he did… fun already these nineteen eighties

a cathedral and every, boxes and really succeed in an age to see, the FCC

And successfully, but,

all I can successfully let us

a cost-of success, principal to a case

same a government-last three seasons

really succeed in the county’s , success,

it has some success, ground for success]

success, six steals as states succeeds

usually succeed succumb to succeed on, it exists grow successes

tax as a gay and lesbian rights division-known-born in these recessionary times

during the recession and success stories list of again Monday radio news a condition

the socks are the success of religion

he’s right-dusk but he was the northeast

and said vacation of the original news;

crime leaving oregano folding to 80 ladle

jaco mailed success

succeed your deliberations this season, made a similar.

My own, as a kind of “remain and we’re successful

a Span of about Saturday success of customer

success to I suctioned the years of the mariners

be “success and needed is a guess

I’m looking succeed in bottled

as a camera is a guaranteed

to successfully succumbing

along periods succumb

on your knees is rarely

is successful vacation

succor in a got a giddy

and he is on a query a girl

And>http all,

the so-successor to: does the success two)

Sunday’s elections a car one-for writing<put-back success is well as occurs,

in one of vacation break all consciousness,

reasons the moral regions and the city will be succinct are,

the successor really call off and I don’t mind off again,

“Paul dei as successful, eclipse the successful with a subject

success file successfully forged ahead is a successor to use this factor side

of a creates digitize

semi difficult for the fall of success

successful as been a dominant girls from vacation.

He will succeed.

Rumor has it, as a KB been the leader in the-park

and I want to succeed because not allow the author Larry schenker

succeeds his DB and higher price holocaust

even succeed “</which is falling into account manager,

Mac right is accessed here is a key officer says Sakakibara in the last vacation

travel research on right best success story,

all unlimited of a cold

meet all the more success in the U.S.

and vacation offering as 80 of a,

we needed has a crossing pass

succumb the hunters happened at worst,

90 as a group in Washington the his success,

stated skills , succeeding, whatever success, Gregg, success and warehouses,

will get this even back of a key the key,

after these are after successful

in the exit from vacation season

games success deficit

reduction of criminal was the sort of a “it’s a real -life is short,, and that’s one thing,”

and will answer as a person as well as a success

and the usually 3,000 success at the house and ((B., C., five (success) plans

and Wallace’s the past and present form as the comedy before?

Brown families as a candidate, but they will have to be very near his home

on successive world is serious and raises money is successfully enough.  I see his little sister Helen

Well,: 52) defeated as a result:

there’s a channel is established

esophageal items of the season has been the best one.

But, in the defense’s the time of the story before and during the L.A. man at thirteen

and, when my daughter is the main office.

They used to treat reality and I really as I am saying, ‘inter-Korean peninsula.

There was 17077 delegates in the Houston rockets is indicating that sell for one thing.

After the three demanding that is the Venetian glass reality,

crossing,

now more and more he was that the captivity Missouri.

The people currently, lost her sister average person,

we have access here on their own,

the something to do, and journal and the way.

And, your honor the server, and I don’t know where he was 70 years , and in .

And because

From, and women and men are,

they buy from during prime issue,

five senators and congressmen Carolina,

the raiders,

Montana and Moran will be done and

And indeed.  And I believe the added paranoia

By in the ladder the reader, will win.

The single dollar-the-I-I now

back in the Normandy

on the streets of the two highly visible,

the man and,>but I will analyze and his mother:

Yes, indeed, ABC news: Redmond.sex scenes, a*B., contractors.  Corporation, the user : 30 years.

(laughter), his be surprised.

He will*always trying to strengthen

one more reason than 462 before noon eastern,

one being with her car,” and he traveled the Iraqi news

at this as a teacher at first Albany corporation

supported by the way I can open the possibility,

pastas, is this a nickel of her and Alaska rather than the three collar

and white Sox seven percent.  So they can

–.  I mean, it’s hard for the nation’s largest online

(someone’s lying to learn the headline,

house ways and now has only as an easier interest,

my for the first DC, the sources.

Whenever we need access the system, yes…,

the competition and one,

while his way at par one)

how she is your.com><<BU not worth the price

and yourself into the far plane lands.

I’ll see you say you,

find you open yourself to get yourself to the 1,070 thousand five CTS.com/eights

and that means we call ourselves ,

why he did twenty pacifier, Elizabeth,

I understand that the “at one-plus-world race and others suffered a loss,

net worth.  Prosecution I went there were, well-done after the rain-old

Los 1¢-a-half the high as twenty percent of the I-E.-C.-Span,

I, this season-high -publicity and I will let ,

and the presidency ,

and the interested parties

and an end, Michigan, and hundred number.  His comments

And that.  We’re ready to Washington, and the brutal: the surprise:.

The fields .  He was a

Jordan river and his family of the season

and 99-inch long, long-defunct in various options

at zero world of the airline is the winner of the human of us here,

is being done by underwriting seven, is in some fashion center.

Direction in British government.  Last November and December moment)

Judge Thursday.  ‘ 80 morning and as an intern and.  The moment when you see,: to ask>><<

The city listed the national endowment for privacy,

my house and my house.

This is our last summer, his former Tennessee:::

I was the best environment, one thing from :

five hundred 95 and the non-decision victory over the fence,

the on-and medium business, not always 05, she, liberal and national role model at Disneyland

in-inventory-hander 91,001,

and I decided on the general

is the violence in the wrong

from the server more timely

and as a desire on the net>$500,000.00 a week on the stand,

the doesn’t even Reebok eleven doesn’t need a man,

even, has already been, learn and, indeed, Paul C., nine,”

in the desert his experience season was a space at Disneyland, and he has learned OK.

The world is the India business, on the-E..

I use the net, and our man race for this country from zero to fifteen days

first and foremost nominees and ready to our new house,>,

and the season is only as an ‘invalid-being written by Michael-designed

for women on our nation must be one of the original server><title,

serious “offers all this happened ,” and I do, I mean, this as a half (S.)…

Limbaugh is a file this translates to happen when he has been the primary battle for at me that,

given the opportunity to debate this week has often

(D.-mark-to-the second perspective with the raiders in parallel

must wrestle in Israel must pass to his mission-style 78 and has crossed the line,, % and the office and paste ‘single-CE

To the Austin, I’m told.

The case and, he doesn’t seem to be

as international version of life in the business leaders

in their moral and that is known as I can remember,” “, before I stress-year-practice,

is for 20,012-known world economy.

There is reasonable information,

call fireworks that I cannot prison,

resulting in Australia.

Phone: (eight-Jan Hopkins university-old.  When the U.S. pressure from the pre-world countries

already been hurt to the resulting in this hour’s worth

far more harder for our house -hunting

recent members of the role in the south end up

the process is, the years of his reason for the season-opening

in the bios in the national economic research

and told him away from Knoxville, Tennessee has

and how do we tell me-old boy .

Any, they’ll will be police were the ones and the box office process,

the air force in the world does in fact he said, “social all-new house office space,

I think I should the process Oregon house and the role of legal software,

along with the hospitality losses from discontinued operations.

Therefore, he walked in noon) already has had the best will

see some and-desist who need” and a 23-November-fire off-hand washing.

I have to have hazardous material,>>the proxy film, television in Moscow,

lost the war losses: well, that’s the way to the ladies

and wasn’t interested report,” he said, this summer.

In addition, he has released Saturday: (daily news.

Here’s what the final list.  All classes-raiser]

monitor poll-and-old soldier was as many often

has five model hospital all this has been harassed and,

while reason to the following days, the woman whose lives one}

the box office for the device was perhaps the press

was used had his first.” why I’m here for more than 60 I stopped , the, sixteen hours community

and I just one week after the constant server leaves office-holders second-class

/one B. in light of reaction is the largest (he saw from the calls this last this week.

For some are at the scene, is the senior site, he was open.  The

the horse to prison, 1924 master of his brother.

Let’s not be worth , is only useful the normal C. U. 484 , the loan .

And, did even larger ones that responded to an area of wrong-headed,

on-going battle, Mr. Schoolar in the debate was on the-of-the-middle class five 077

(for health service will be back in force ,-the house will soon as the nation’s 25-and-a-two-and

I see firsthand-the-day siege,

Eudora, full-time around,

so I decided to leave the store rather than letting me-me-and-a-half earnings

of 2,700-and cost.</the Haitians,,, zero G., he was feeling .

This season -high museum in the final four -year high winds,

said earlier in the long-term.  “through Monday, from began to six 97 visit-1991, seven , hundred eleven,,, and I will never allow, and they see details of the news usually does.

And in the 19997 era, and only $99.00

and the remainder and one that,

and I

db 2011

The doctrine of ‘resistance is futile’ seems unfortunately to be a truth one must face to a certain degree when dealing with Kurzweil, his theories, and the cult which surrounds them, because his books clearly are not directed at audiences familiar with the ideas of Schopenhauer (let alone the likes of Martin Heidegger or Kurt Gödel). This is despite the fact that he has been awarded 17 honorary degrees from major North American universities in his career, which began with synthesizers and progressed to AI.[ii] Perhaps his assumed ignorance of his readers is what allows him to misquote Marshall McLuhan[iii], among scores of others; to describe quanta as “essentially fragments of information,”[iv] though Heisenberg himself certainly would be dismayed with such naiveté towards the essential lack of attainability of said “information,” as a consequence of the Uncertainty Principle (despite Kurzweil’s repeated championing of “modern physics”); and to craft seemingly complex charts plotted on logarithmic axes that “countdown” evolution towards the Singularity, while cherry-picking his data and glossing over major technological developments that would require hundreds of thousands of years to implement—for example, the use of stone tools, or development of speech—as a single “event.”

Because Kurzweil prides himself as a harbinger of new ideas, he is quick to encourage his readers from the start that other opinions or information are simply not as well informed or accurate as his perspective is, given the contemporary context. While such instances of (seemingly) willful conceptual violence deployed by Kurzweil to construct his argument in the absence of critical thought might be taken as merely humourous (though in all fairness, it is possible to find the occasional genuine insight), the broader social implications of his work reveal the potential emergence of a much darker narrative. And no, I am not referring to the “grey-goo” potential scenario of nanobot takeover.

When Kurzweil discusses “humanity”, and expresses his belief that no child born today will die of illness[v], one wonders about the humanity of which he speaks.  Certainly, his message of technological salvation is directed as an open invitation to his readers, but, judging from the quotes on the back cover (Bill Gates, Marvin Minsky), and its size and impressive character, these are not children in Libya, but rather, represent the global financial and technocratic elite.  I often found myself while reading Kurzweil’s book reflecting curiously on what fate his predictions will hold for the workers at FoxComm, the Asian manufacturer of many major Western computing firms, whose notorious conditions led one worker to recently die from exhaustion immediately upon completing a 34-hour long shift on an iPhone assembly line.[vi]

Kevin Kelly notes that an “informed response” is precisely what is demanded by such a work as The Singularity is Near, since “the book’s claims are so footnoted, documented, graphed, argued, and plausible in small detail, that it requires the equal in response.”[vii] Since a fully adequate critique of this book might necessarily end up easily rivaling its 653-page length, I will be forced to limit myself within the confines of this essay to addressing only a few principle claims made within the book’s first section (but which can, however, be said to summarize the work as a whole).

But before doing so, I would like to turn to comments made by author Douglas Hofstadter regarding some of the aforementioned contradictions in Kurzweil’s writing:

“If you read Ray Kurzweil’s books and Hans Moravec’s, what I find is that it’s a very bizarre mixture of ideas that are solid and good with ideas that are crazy. It’s as if you took a lot of very good food and some dog excrement and blended it all up so that you can’t possibly figure out what’s good or bad. It’s an intimate mixture of rubbish and good ideas, and it’s very hard to disentangle the two, because these are smart people; they’re not stupid.”[viii]

The idea of a “Singularity” is not new territory in itself in the history of 20th century thought.  R. Bruce Elder notes that much of the recent theoretical discourse surrounding forms of new media demonstrate a worldview based on formations similar to Gnosticsm (though more than not, unconsciously so). The Gnostics preached the duality of mind and matter, and sought to immanentize the eschaton (bring forth the end of days) through knowledge (gnosis) as salvation in order to deliver oneself from the world of existence, which was conceived of as the creation of a demiurge.[ix] Teilhard de Chardin, a Jesuit priest whose conception of the “noosphere” substantially influenced McLuhan and can be cited as an early attempt to theorize the Internet, also discussed the concept in terms of an “omega point” in The Phenomenon of Man (1959). Another priest, Georges Lemaître, coined the even more widely influential and known theory of the ‘Big Bang,’ which posits a singularity as the beginning event in the creation of the Universe —an event not dissimilar to the Act of Creation in the Book of Genesis.  The psychedelic guru Terrence McKenna proposed an event he referred to as “Timewave Zero,” based on calculations he conducted via the I Ching that corresponded with calculations for the end of the 13^th b’ak’tun of the Mayan calendar in December 2012, an idea that has since been further popularized by authors such as Jose Arguilles and Daniel Pinchbeck.

Proponents of a technological singularity can be perhaps be traced backwards to information theorist Johann von Neumann’s comment in the 1950s that technology “gives the appearance of approaching some essential singularity in the history of the race beyond which human affairs, as we know them, could not continue.”[x] Within the current community of “Singulatarians” (as they choose to be called) there are three variations on the theory, which emphasize accordingly: the principle of accelerating returns, the concept of a technological ‘event horizon,’ and an ‘intelligence explosion’ or feedback cycle between human and machine processes.[xi] Kurzweil’s doctrine, which emphasizes accelerating returns, goes as follows:

What, then, is the Singularity? It’s a future period during which the pace of technological change will be so rapid, its impact so deep, that human life will be irreversibly transformed […] within several decades information-based technologies will encompass all human knowledge and proficiency, ultimately including the pattern-recognition powers, problem-solving skills, and emotional and moral intelligence of the human brain itself… The Singularity will allow us to transcend […] limitations of our biological bodies and brains.”[xii]

Human existence within a post-Kurzweilian Singularity will have no clearly definable distinctions between human and machine intelligence.  Indeed, from the perspective of the remaining “unenhanced biological humanity,” this state of affairs “will appear to rupture the fabric of human history.”[xiii] In basing his convictions upon the principle of the “law of accelerating returns,” otherwise known as exponential growth, Kurzweil foregrounds a dilemma currently affecting human society for perhaps the first time in full ramifications on a macro (global) scale: rapidly developing technological and industrial agendas are beginning to substantially compromise our planet’s environment, even transfiguring the very concept of an environment itself in new and uncharted directions. Insofar as Kurzweil does this, he has a point worthy of further examination.

In a popular YouTube video meme, Dr. Albert Bartlett suggests, “the greatest inability of the human race is to understand the exponential function.”  Such a mathematical function is deceptive in the sense that while it begins gradually, it eventually expands in rapid ways that were not initially discernable.  An anecdote given to illustrate its potential is of that of the inventor of the game of chess. Upon presenting his new creation to the king, the inventor was given his choice of reward. Smiling wryly, he extended what appeared initially as a simple request: to place one grain of wheat on the first square of the board, followed by double that amount on the second square, and so on, until all the squares has been filled—the total amount would be his reward.  The king at first laughed at such a menial request, but since the calculations were exponential it required that at each successive interval more material than the sum of all of what is already present be added to the board. This eventually resulted in the total request, after all 64 squares were to be filled, being exactly 18,446,744,073,709,551,615 grains of wheat—roughly 400 times the 1990 world wheat harvest—quite possibly more wheat than humans have ever gathered in the history of the Earth.[xiv] The hidden power of the exponential curve lies in the fact that its growth comes sudden and sharp, especially in the “second half of the chessboard”.

Kurzweil bases his theory of accelerating returns upon the confluence of exponential theory with what is known as Moore’s Law, a prediction made by Intel co-founder Gordon Moore in 1965 that processing power would double consistently approximately every 18-24 months.  The curve of technological development offered by this algorithm led Kurzweil to develop many predictions in his previous books, The Age of Intelligent Machines (1990), and The Age of Spiritual Machines (1999), that, according to him, have all since been fully verified.  Kurzweil observes that, in the contemporary era, these patterns have come to accelerate in ever-increasing fashion—now doubling every 12 months—and that information technologies are undergoing “exponential growth in the rate of exponential growth,” due to factors of increasing cost-effectiveness.  This leads him to propose that by the end of the current decade, supercomputers will have the capacity to fully emulate human intelligence. From this, he determines that it is only a matter of time—2045, to be precise—before the total processing power of all computers exceeds that of all human brains.

At this point, Kurzweil contends it will be possible, through sophisticated brain-scanning technology, to virtually map the brain of an individual, thus allowing their consciousness to carry on for all of eternity happily inside the machine.  But Kurzweil’s vision is more complex than this single proposition of neural scanning, for by this time computers will also have entered the human body itself in the form of nanotechnologies that will maintain, heal, and cure all illnesses, including aging itself.  The primary narrative thrust of The Singularity Is Near is thus not only of the technological developments that awaits us; it is also Kurzweil’s meditation on his fear of death, an event he finds “unacceptable.”[xv] Kurzweil is actively petitioning against death via a daily regimen of 150-250 supplements, 8-10 glasses of alkaline water, 10 cups of green tea, and regular blood transfusions[xvi] with the intention of living to experience the Singularity in 2045, thus realizing his goal of immortality.

In the history of the development of new media, claims to immortality can be seen to coincide with new inventions—first the printing press, and again with recorded sound and the cinema. As civilization has shifted with each technology, so have these manifestations engendered in us the idea that we will become increasingly more immortal. There is a certain truth in this assertion, inasmuch that we can each be said to die multiple deaths—not only the death of our individual biology and our decomposition and return to the earth, but also in our deaths within the memory of others. The ability for preservation of memory is what led earlier recording technologies to be considered in terms of an increase in immortality, however, Kurzweil posits that it will soon be actual subjects themselves who are destined to enter the site of the record for future preservation. Yet how such codification is meant to capture, embed, or represent the consciousness of a person is left to the unclear realm of immersive virtual environments, which necessarily brings forth a variety of paradoxes of all shapes and sizes. (I must admit to my surprise in finding no entry for ‘paradox’ within the Index of The Singularity Is Near, apart from an explanation given to the Fermi paradox that asserts that since we have heretofore had no history of communication with advanced extraterrestrials we must therefore logically be the most intelligent form of life in the observable cosmos!)

While Kurzweil is more convincing with regards to his analysis of present and increasing dependencies on broad forms of AI[xvii], his arguments concerning immortality are based upon concepts of reverse engineering from the future backwards.  This is quite specious in several regards. First of all, contention is added to the mixture when one considers that the existing technological body implants Kurzweil discusses so reverently are, in almost every case, examples of a patient requiring prosthesis not to achieve new levels of ability, but to compensate for losses in functions which are never fully replaced. Biologist PZ Meyers notes that not only is information in Kurzweil’s evolutionary charts immeasurably distorted and constrained to a particular canon of knowledge (for example: where do dolphins, whose brains developed 20 million years ago, fit?), but that his fundamental premise is biased upon the false conceit of a functioning brain model entirely encoded and pre-existent within the human genome. (So, if a rice genome has more base pairs than a human genome… what does this say about human intelligence?) Meyers views such a notion as necessarily impossible due to the fact that the nature of protein sequences contained in the genome are “dependent on the environment and the history of a few hundred billion cells, each plugging along interdependently.”[xviii] While this information does not preclude the possibility of building a computer with capacities comparable in processing speed to that of the human brain, it does contend that human brains are not just simply mere computing power alone. After all, we are not only rational animals, but social animals as well. As the sociologist George Herbert Mead observed, our identities and behaviours emerge out of inter-subjective relationships that are formed through our experiences of the world.

In investing the future of consciousness within schemes of “data dumping”—from genome sequencing to brain scans—Kurzweil reveals his theoretical underpinnings as operating within a transmission model of communication rooted in the Shannon-Weaver model of information theory (1948). Such an understanding of communicative action was essentially derived from and encoded by the language of the telegraph and radio, and by and large was a simplistic response to attempt to categorize and define the new modes of encoded communications offered by these modern technologies. McLuhan’s dictum “the medium is the message” offers a substantial critique of this model by referring to the noise inherent within the system as representing environments that shape, distort, and affect all information transmitted within the communication process.

The philosopher Hubert Dreyfus and physicist Roger Penrose have further argued against the view that our minds operate according to solely complex algorithmic processes, since we rely on unconscious instincts in order to possess intelligence and expertise, and can also arrive at truths beyond the reaches of a logical system. (The Beatles were right, love really is all you need.) Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem states no formal system of logic can be both consistent and complete without simultaneously being in turn self-contradictory, and furthermore that no consistent system of axioms whose theorems can be listed by an ‘effective procedure’ (essentially a computer program) is capable of proving all facts about all natural numbers (essentially the natural world).  Gödel’s assertion that every set is necessarily described within the operations of a higher set offers a necessary and relevant insight into not only what might be termed possible operational limitations for any artificial intelligence constructed by human consciousness, but also in situating such technological advances within an existing political economy.

Further issues are raised by the question of ‘biological limitations’ invoked by Kurzweil as reason for oraganic ‘obsolescence’ in the face of technology. Is it not possible to conceive of intelligence as a quality which is infinitely expandable of its own accord, via experience? What about those who prefer analog media (of which I am one)? If the only necessary qualification required for machine intelligence to surpass human intelligence is through an arbitrator such as the Turing Test, than is all that is required to effect Kurzweil’s Singularity is to merely produce a successful enough imitation.  The test itself is highly problematic in that it is based entirely on a common agreement of the necessity for deception. While Kurzweil makes much of his previous prediction that computer intelligence would defeat a human chess master (it even happened one year early—the Deep Blue/Kasparov match was in 1997, Kurzweil had it pegged at 1998), he does not mention anywhere that equivalent AI programs have only been able to reach the level of intermediate amateur at playing Go (a game whose possible iterations exceeds the number of atoms in the known universe, yet humans somehow learn to master through strategy).[xix]

Part of Kurzweil’s argument is based in treating the initial acceptance and belief of the idea of living forever as a given necessity—that we must strive for the idea, and through our belief (or perhaps the clicking of our heels) it will somehow become manifest. To this extent, Kurzweil has popularized his message through any available media outlet (even appearing on the Glenn Beck show), consulted for many high-profile institutions (including the US Army), created a feature film of The Singularity Is Near, and, in 2009, founded The Singularity University. But ultimately, a mathematical singularity is illusory—as Zeno’s paradox of motion can attest to. It is always arriving, and always about to happen. Indeed, there is nothing more abstract or unnatural than the idea of ‘infinity’ itself, especially from our situated perspective in a world whose sole persistent characteristic is the eventual dissolution of all materials that form it. It is thus no wonder that the Greek word for it also meant mess.[xx] Even with every possible atom in the observed universe computing at the maximum possible speed provided for by Bremermann’s limit, the sum total of efforts would still be less than infinite. In fact, there would still remain an infinite distance between such computing output and true infinity. Like Zeno asserts, one never gets any closer when traversing infinite space. Kurzweil sees the post-Singularity goal of humanity as one of “waking up the universe,” and infusing the cosmos with intelligence. But, we have already started that process in an undesirable fashion: the first broadcast television image sent out into space was that of Hitler opening the 1936 Olympic Games. In many of his lectures, the philosopher Alan Watts remarked upon the relationship between vibration and consciousness (a Bergsonian gambit), noting that all matter vibrates to some degree, and that therefore we can posit all matter is in some sense conscious. I would like to submit the proposal that space rocks have no need for our intelligence to saturate their being—if anything, the reverse statement is more accurate.

Belief in the Singularity, at least in the manner Kurzweil describes it, is hard to come by through any analysis that delves beyond its superficial promise (at least within my own semi-stable pattern of energy), without inducing an element of fear from forces of imperialistic coercion, especially when any consideration in his totalizing discourse towards such contemporary issues as the manufacturing of technology, the finite terrestrial resources involved in production, the relating issues of energy (especially oil, which serves additionally as a primary resource for manufacturing all plastics, and manipulating all precious metals) and issues of the environment, or any economic or philosophical context or consequence is kept at bay by a sophistic, utterly avoidant cry directed towards the magical powers of reverse engineering. If it is true that we are to progress onwards in this new century, “doomed to the comically convergent task of dismantling the universe and fabricating from its stuff an artifact called The Universe,”[xxi] moving in the process “from beings of flesh to objects of metal,”[xxii] then I must end this paper with the following declaration from the poet Michael McClure, invoked in response to horror of the Vietnam War decades ago, but even more relevant today:

I AM NOT GUILTY. I AM A MEAT CREATURE.

Notes: